District Court, S.D. New York February 7, 1924 (The J. C. Hartt)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-02-1924

GODDARD, District Judge.

These are suits brought to recover damages alleged to have been sustained as a result of á collision between a tow of barges bound up the Hudson river, with the steam canal boat Ulster having in tow four canal boats coming down.

The tug Hartt, assisted by the tug Decker, left New York City on September 28, 1920, with a fleet of 47 barges, some light and some loaded in tow astern with a hawser of 75 fathoms, there being six boats abreast in the hawser or first tier; these being referred to hereafter as the Cornell tow.

The Ulster, a steam canal boat, was coming down from Troy and had 4 loaded barges in tow. Her tow was made up with a barge fast to her port side, another barge on her starboard, and two barges astern on short hawsers. The collision occurred on September 29, 1920, at about 8 p. m. north of West Point just below Magazine Point; the tide was strong ebb, and, owing to the bend in the river, sets strong to the west. The river in this vicinity is about 1,400 feet wide. The Ulster and her tow were moving with the tide about 6 miles an hour and the up-bound tow between 1 and 2 miles an hour.

The starboard barge of the Ulster tow came, in contact with the starboard side of the head tier of the Cornell tow, and as a result two boats in the Cornell tow sank and other boats in both tows were damaged.

Two libels were filed by Mylott, one being in rem against the tug Hartt alone, and the other being in personam against the Cornell Steamboat Company, presumably to recover any alleged damage which might not be recoverable against the Hartt itself. The libel of Whitehead Bros, was on account of alleged damage to and loss of cargo which was on the Mylott; the other libels were for alleged damages to barges.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.