Supreme Court of Arkansas June 9, 1924 (Fidelity Phenix Fire Insurance v. Roth)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-06-1924
Smith, J.
This is a suit on a fire insurance policy issued by the appellant insurance company. The property insured was described as two thousand or more bushels of rice, and it was consumed or damaged by fire. The policy contains the following provision: “This entire policy, unless otherwise provided by agreement indorsed herein or added hereto, shall be void if the subject of insurance be personal property and be or become incumbered by a chattel mortgage. ’ ’
At the time of the fire there were two mortgages on the rice, one in favor of the First National Bank of DeWitt and another in favor of the Arkansas Light & Power Company, but there was no notation in regard to either on the policy.
It is admitted that the insurance company knew of the mortgage to the bank before the policy was issued; in fact, the agent for the insurance company called on the cashier of the bank to inquire whether the bank would pay the premium, and the company’s agent was told that the bank would pay the premium because it had a mortgage on the rice. The company admits that its liability cannot be defeated on account of the mortgage to the bank, because its agent knew of this mortgage, but the company denies liability on account of the mortgage to the Arkansas Light & Power Company, of which it claims to have had no knowledge. We think, however, that the testimony sufficiently supports the finding of the jury that the agent of the insurance company who wrote the policy of insurance was also advised of this mortgage, and, this being true, the provision of the policy in regard to incumbrance will be held to have been waived. National Union Fire Ins. Co. v. Kent, 163 Ark. 7, and cases there cited.
The suit was brought for the face of the policy, which was $2,000, and judgment was rendered for that amount, to which was added the statutory penalty of 12 per cent, and an allowance for attorney’s fees. It is insisted that the undisputed proof shows that the damage from the fire was only $1,728.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit