Tennessee Supreme Court December 15, 1924 (Smith v. Tucker)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-12-1924

Mr. Thomas H. Malone, Special Judge,

delivered the opinion of the Court.

These two suits, heard together in the trial court and in the court of civil appeals, are based on the alleged wrongful killing of the infant son of the plaintiff in error. The first suit is brought by Smith for loss of services, and the second suit in his character as administrator.

The trial judge sustained a motion for peremptory instructions in each case, and the court of civil appeals, in a majority opinion delivered by the late Chief Justice WilsoN, affirmed the judgments. Both parties bring the cases here by certiorari, the plaintiff in error on the ground that the suits were improperly dismissed, the defendant in error on the ground that the court of civil appeals failed to sustain the defense of contributory negligence.

The questions involved appear to he not only of first impression here, hut the diligence of counsel has not furnished the court, nor has the court found, any authority from, any jurisdiction in point.

*350Briefly stated, the insistence of the plaintiff in error is that the doctrine of the “Willcox Cases” (Hines v. Willcox [1895], 96 Tenn., 148, 33 S. W., 914, 34 L. R. A., 824, 54 Am. St. Rep., 923, and Stenberg v. Willcox [1895]. 96 Tenn., 163, 33 S. W., 917, 34 L. R. A., 615; same cases, 100 Tenn., 524, 45 S. W., 781, 66 Am. St. Rep., 761, and 100 Tenn., 538, 46 S. W., 297, 41 L. R. A., 278, 66 Am. St. Rep., 770; and Cotton Press & Storage Co. v. Miller [1916], 135 Tenn., 187, 186 S. W., 87, L. R. A., 1916F, 1139) may and should he extended to the relation of vendor and purchaser.

The petitions of the respective parties (w-ho will be styled as they were in the court below) raise these' essential questions:

(a) Was there a breach of duty on the part of the defendant, Tucker, which makes him liable in damages to the plaintiff, Smith, as administrator, on account of the child’s death?

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.