District Court, S.D. California May 28, 1925 (United States v. Pan-American Petroleum Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-05-1925

McCORMICK, District Judge.

This is a suit in equity, wherein the United States of America seeks to have declared null, void, and. of no effect two contracts, dated April 25, 1922, and December 11, 1922, respectively, and two oil and gas leases to lands in the naval petroleum reserves in California, dated June 5, 1922, and December 11, 1922, respectively. The prayer of the bill is that these agreements and leases be canceled, for an accounting, and for general relief. The relief is sought upon two grounds: First, fraud in the making of the contracts and leases; and,'second, lack of legal authority for their making.

The ease has received the careful consideration that its importance demands, but existing circumstances, due to pressure and volume of work in the court, do- not admit of the preparation of a detailed opinion upon every issue. • The formal decision upon all issues consists of the findings of fact and conclusions of law filed herewith. I feel impelled, however, to amplify such decision by this statement.

I will first consider the charge of fraud and official misconduct in the making of the contracts and leases in suit; and, secondly, whether the agreements were made pursuant to any legal authorization. The first involves mixed questions of law and fact, while the latter is solely a legal question. The contracts and leases in suit may be epitomized as follows:

The agreement of April 25, 1922, is between the Pan-American Petroleum & Transport Company, a corporation, called the “contractor,” and the United States of America, by the Acting Secretary of the Interior and the Secretary of the Navy thereof, denominated the “government.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.