Arizona Supreme Court October 9, 1925, Civil No. 2378. (Mack v. Boots)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-10-1925

*117

ROSS, J.

— This appeal is from the allowance of an exemption of an automobile to Charles Boots as against an execution levied thereon to satisfy a judgment theretofore obtained against Boots by C. M. Mack.

The question of exemption was presented to the trial court on motion to vacate levy, supported by affidavit. At the hearing on motion oral testimony was submitted by both parties. Some complaint is made of this summary method of procedure, but we think it the usual and proper way to raise the question of exemption when property is attached or levied upon under execution. The motion was based upon two grounds: (1) That the automobile was obtained by Boots in a trade of his homestead; and (2) that Boots was a licensed chauffeur and as such used the automobile habitually to earn his living. The court found that the evidence sustained both claims, and ordered the levy vacated and set aside. Mack appeals and assigns as error the order sustaining the first claim as contrary to the law, and the order sustaining the second claim as contrary to the law and not supported by the evidence.

Under the statute, when a homestead is involuntarily converted into personal property, as under execution or attachment sale, the sum of $4,000 is “protected from all legal process” (paragraph 3295, Civ. Code 1913), but when the sale is voluntary the statute is silent. Some of the courts hold, under such circumstances, that if the sale of the homestead was made with the intention of reinvesting the proceeds in another homestead, such proceeds are exempt until reinvested, providing it is done within a reasonable time.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.