Arizona Supreme Court May 22, 1925, Civil No. 2289. (Babbitt & Cowden Livestock Co. v. Hooker)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-05-1925

LOCKWOOD, J.

Babbitt

&

Cowden Live Stock Company, a corporation, hereinafter called plaintiff,

*265

filed suit against C. H. Hooker, hereinafter called defendant, alleging substantially that on March 20th, 1922, plaintiff was the owner and entitled to the possession of some thirty (30) registered Hereford bulls, worth $4,500, which were temporarily in the custody of the Blaney Land & Cattle Company; that defendant Hooker, with full knowledge of plaintiff’s rights, wrongfully took possession of and converted the same to his own use; that demand had been"made for the return of the animals, but it was refused by Hooker, to plaintiff’s damage in the sum of $4,500.

Defendant interposed various motions, demurrers, and a general denial, and then raised his real defense by various pleas in bar and an estoppel. The first plea in bar alleges defendant’s possession was by virtue of an execution sale under order of court, and that if there was any conversion it was made by a receiver of the court. The second is substantially to the same effect. The third denies plaintiff’s ownership and right to possession of the bulls, and alleges they had been bought by the Blaney Land & Cattle Company from plaintiff, and by the terms of a certain mortgage which had been foreclosed by the court, they had been legally sold to defendant. The plea of estoppel sets up that plaintiff by its conduct was estopped from denying the ownership of the Blaney Land & Cattle Company as against defendant.

Plaintiff replied to these pleas, denying the matter set up therein, and alleged that defendant had full knowledge of plaintiff’s ownership of the cattle when he took them, and recognized its rights therein. This assertion was denied later by the defendant.

The case was tried by the court without a jury. Plaintiff introduced certain evidence, and, at the close of its case, defendant, without offering any evidence, moved for judgment, which motion after due consideration was granted by the court.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.