Court of Appeals of Kentucky (pre-1976) November 17, 1925 (Downing v. Whitlow)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-11-1925

*295

Opinion op the Court by

Judge Sampson

Reversing.

The questions presented by this appeal are, whether the note for $3,000.00 signed by appellees, Gertrude Whitlow and husband, W. R. Whitlow, payable to Mrs. H. S. Cox, was given by the latter to the former in such manner as to constitute a gift

inter vivos;

and, if not so, was the note in suit executed and delivered without consideration?

In January, 1923, Mrs. Benna W. Cox died testate a resident of and domiciled in Jefferson county, Kentucky. .She made her will some years before designating appellant, John R. Downing, as executor. Appellee, Mrs. Gertrude H. Whitlow, a niece of the testatrix, was the principal 'beneficiary.

The original petition in the suit by the executor .averred that the note for $3,000.00, reading:

“December 15th, 1912.

“$3,000.00.

“One day after date I promised to pay to Mrs. H. S. Cox, $3,000.00, three thousand dollars, with ■interest at six per cent payable annually.

“Mrs. Gertrude Whitlow,

“W. R. Whitlow,"

was in the possession of the payee, Mrs. H. S. Cox, and that she gave the note to her niece, Mrs. Gertrule Whit-low, and promised to deliver it to Mrs. Whitlow, and instructed Mrs. Whitlow, in case she did not deliver the note to her in her lifetime, to take possession of it and ■destroy it herself, it being the theory of the pleader that the note had been given by the payee to the payor in such way and manner as to constitute a gift

inter vivos.

The pleading, however, showed the note had not been delivered by the payee to the payor. Later the petition was -amended, the averments, in substance, being that the person named as payee in the note had given to- the person named as payor in the note $3,000.00’ with which

io

build a home in a village in Warren county, and that after the money had been delivered and used in the construction of the home and the gift fully consummated, the giver asked Mrs.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.