Court of Appeals of Kentucky (pre-1976) March 24, 1925 (Witt v. Louisville & Nashville Railroad)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-03-1925

Opinion oi? the» Court by

Commissioner Sandidge

Affirming.

Appellants, O. W. Witt and others, own a farm in Estill county, Kentucky, containing something over 400 acres. The tracks of appellee, Louisville & Nashville Railroad Company, traverse that farm. They sued to compel it to re-establish a farm crossing and a station on the farm which they alleged it had wrongfully discontinued and to compel it to erect certain fences. Alternatively they pleaded that, in the event they were not entitled to that relief, they were entitled to damages in the sum of $5,000.00. Appellants had purchased the farm

*127

from S. P. Crawford, who conveyed it to them March 26, 1919. Crawford had purchased the farm from R. P. Wagers, who conveyed it to him December 31, 1912. Appellants’ right to the relief sought in their petition was founded upon a contract made by R. P. Wagers while she owned the tract of land with the Richmond, Nicholas-ville, Irvine and Beattyville Railroad Company at the time that company procured the right of way through it upon which appellee’s railroad tracks are now maintained. Appellee interposed many defenses to the cause of action pleaded in plaintiffs’ petition, by all of which appellants’ right to any relief was contested. The various defenses, noted hereinafter in the discussion of the questions presented, were appropriately pleaded. The chancellor dismissed their petition and they appeal.

The record discloses the following facts:

After the organization of the Richmond, Nieholasville, Irvine and Beattyville Railroad Company, which will be hereinafter called the R. N. I.

&

B. Ry. Company, it instituted condemnation proceedings in the Estill county court to procure a right of way across the farm then owned by R. P. Wagers and her children, who were the surviving widow and heirs of her husband, who had died intestate, the owner of it, and it is the same farm now owned by appellants.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.