Court of Appeals of Kentucky (pre-1976) November 27, 1925 (Riddle Coal Company v. Bell)
Also known as
United States · · · 27-11-1925
*510
Opinion of the Court by
Judge Dietzman
Affirming-
In August, 1920, appellee was the operator or controlled the output of two coal mines near Pineville, Kentucky, and appellant, a partnership,' was a coal broker. On August 14,1920, the parties entered into the following contract:
“Pineville, Ky., August 14, 1920.
“Biddle Coal Co., Pineville, Ky.
“Gentlemen: This is to confirm sale to you of twenty-four cars of mine run coal, to be shipped at rate of two cars per week, either from the Mason seam at Ferndale, Ky., or Straight 'Creek seam at Beams, Ky., at $9.50 per ton f. o. b. mines.
“It is thoroughly understood that you are to take this coal regardless of the condition of the market, and I 'bind myself to ship same regardless of the market.
“(Signed) M. D. Bell.
“Accepted:
Biddle Coal Co.
By D. S. Biddle.
By G. W. Johnson.”
On the same day after the signing of this contract appellant sent to appellee the following order:
“August 14, 1920.
“To M. D. Bell: Ship to Florida China Clay Corp., at Oklahumpka, Fla., 24 cars of mine run, 2 cars per week, price per ton $9.50 f. o. b. mines, available equipment. And gives the shipping instruction, freight prepaid. Have billing agent call the office.”
Under the contract and order, appellee shipped no coal until August 24th, when he sent forward one car. From then until the first of November he shipped 17 cars, but at very irregular intervals, and not at the rate of two cars per week. All of these 17 cars he did ship, however, were received and accepted by the consignee without complaint on its part or on that of appellant. About the first of November, 1920, the Florida concern requested appellant to hold up further shipments of coal to it, and thereupon appellant requested appellee to hold
*511
up the balance of the seven cars unshipped until further notice. But that appellant considered the contract of August 14, 1920, then still in existence is clear from the testimony of D. S.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit