Court of Appeals of Kentucky (pre-1976) November 13, 1925 (McCoy v. Mud Lick Coal Company)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-11-1925

*210

Opinion op the Court by

Drury, Commissioner

Affirming.

■The appellants, whom we will call plaintiffs, began this action against the appellee and W. M. York, to remove an alleged clond from their title. They were unsuccessful in the trial court and have appealed. By deed dated February 2, 1924, and of record in deed book 75, page 230, in the office of the clerk of the Pike county court, LeBoy Bunyon, then 'an infant, acquired title to a tract of land which it appears contains twenty-seven acres. On May 3, 1917, LeBoy Bunyon — while an infant —gave a very elaborate coal and mining lease to> W. M. York. In the descriptive part of this lease, the premises are described as acquired under deed dated February 2, 1914, and of record in deed book 75, at page 230, in the Pike county clerk’s office, though stated to contain 21.44 acres. This lease was on November 24, 1917, recorded in Pike county, deed book 91, at page 280, and this lease was by York transferred to the Mud Lick Coal Company.

On April 1,1918, Dr. John B. Maynard, as guardian of LeBoy Bunyon, gave a still more elaborate lease on these premises to the Mud Lick Coal Company, the premises being again described by reference to the deed by which title was acquired, and to its date, and the book and page where it is recorded; but in this deed the premises were stated to contain forty acres, more or less. This lease was recorded in Pike county, deed book 92, page 101, on April 3, 1918. The lease was made under the authority of chapter 116 of the laws of Kentucky for 1918, same being now section 2031a-l-6 of the statutes. Dr. Maynard undertook to make a lease for forty-five years. It is insisted that because of ¡section 2031a-2, this was an effort on his part to make a lease beyond the time when the infancy of LeBoy Bunyon would be at an end, and that therefore the lease was void.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.