Court of Appeals of Kentucky (pre-1976) March 27, 1925 (Himler Coal Co. v. Ella and Albert Kirk)
Also known as
United States · · · 27-03-1925
*29
Opinion of the Court by
Commissioner Hobson
Reversing.
Appellees own a tract of land in Martin county.. The Himler Coal Company proposed to build a line of railway up the bottom from the Norfolk & Western Railway to its coal mine. This line crossed a corner of appellees’ tract. They forbade the building of the railway on the ground that under its title papers the coal company had no right-of-way there. Thereupon the coal company filed, a petition in equity to enjoin‘the appellees from interfering with it in building the line of railway across the corner of their land. The coal company obtained a preliminary injunction, which on motion was dissolved by the circuit court. It then brought the ease before a judge of this court, who reinstated the injunction. While this action was still pending appellees brought this suit against the coal company charging that it had entered upon their land without right and destroyed buildings, etc., to their damage in the sum of $20,000.00. The coal company filed an answer denying 'the allegations of the petition, pleading its title and pleading the pendency of the equity action in abatement of the action for damages, alleging that that action was in the same court and undecided. A demurrer to. this paragraph of the answer was sustained by the court. At a subsequent term the court dismissed the equity action. The coal company appealed with supersedeas. It then filed an amended answer setting up these facts and praying the court to postpone the trial of the action for damages until the appeal was heard in this court. The court overruled the motion, and the action for damages coming on for hearing before a jury, instructed the jury in substance that the coal company was a trespasser and liable for the damages sued for and that the jury might in their discretion allow punitive damages. The jury found for the plaintiff and fixed the damages at $5,500.00. The coal company appeals.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit