Supreme Court of Minnesota January 9, 1925, No. 24,282. (Morrow v. Porter)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-01-1925

Dibell, J.

Action by plaintiff, a daughter of Henry V. Klock, deceased, against Fred K. Porter, his administrator, and his heirs for the specific enforcement of an agreement to devise a residence property in Fairmont, in consideration of her furnishing him a home and care and support during his life. Whether such agreement was made, and performed by the plaintiff, was submitted to a jury. There were findings for the plaintiff and the defendants appeal from the order denying their motion for a new trial.

The deceased, Klock, was a widower 81 years of age at his death on December 9, 1922. The plaintiff and the defendants, other than the administrator, are his children. In the spring of 1920 Klock bought the residence property in controversy. The plaintiff and her husband occupied it, and cared for and supported him, with the interruptions now to be noted, until his death. For a period from May, 1921, to October, 1921, another daughter occupied the home and cared for her father. There was some disagreement or misunderstanding at the time. In October, 1921, the plaintiff moved back, and resumed the care of her father. From

*398

May to October, 1922, she cooked for ber husband in bis camp on a ditch contract some miles from tbe city, and lived there. During this period sbe and ber husband frequently drove to tbe city in their auto and attended to tbe decedent’s needs. He was very deaf, bad other infirmities, and was difficult to get along with. His care involved tbe performance of disagreeable services. Tbe evidence justifies a finding that an agreement such as is claimed was made; that when tbe plaintiff returned in tbe fall of 1921 it was reaffirmed; and that tbe plaintiff assumed a personal and domestic relation towards tbe decedent and rendered services so difficult of compensation in money as to warrant a specific performance. Colby v. Street, 146 Minn. 290, 178 N. W. 599, and cases cited; Odenbreit v. Utheim, 131 Minn. 56, 154 N. W. 741, L. R. A.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.