Supreme Court of Minnesota December 31, 1925, Nos. 24,952, 24,938. (Citizens St. Bank of St. Paul v. Wade)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-12-1925

Holt, J.

The appeal concerns three actions. One is the Citizens State Bank of St. Paul v. Cyrus Wade, in ejectment, tried by Hon. A. E. Giddings, where a verdict was directed for plaintiff, but, on de

*398

fendant’s motion, the verdict was vacated and a new trial granted. The bank appeals from the order. The other appeal is from the judgments rendered in two actions consolidated and tried together by Hon. C. M. Tifft, sitting in place of Judge Grid dings, the one action being by Cyrus and Dora W'ade against the Citizens State Bank of St. Paul, affecting the title to the same land involved in the ejectment suit, and the other being by the bank against the Wades for the replevin of personal property covered by a chattel mortgage; the appeal from each judgment being by the bank, and a cross appeal by the Wades in the land suit.

Dismissal of Appeal in Action in Ejectment.

The appeal in the first mentioned case must be dismissed. It is taken from an order granting a new trial on a motion specifying, among other grounds, that the verdict was contrary to the evidence. In the order there is no statement that it was granted exclusively for errors of law. A memorandum subjoined to the order reads: “A new trial is granted in this action upon the authority of Trust Company v. Dokko, 72 Minn. 229, the principles announced in the cases therein cited and approved by our Supreme Court. I regret that my attention was not called to this at the trial.” This is not stating expressly that a new trial was granted exclusively for errors of law, and hence the order is not appealable. Our latest ruling upon this point, Miller v. County of Steele, 162 Minn. 85, 202 N. W. 68, requires a dismissal of the appeal from the order.

Actions to Cancel Deed and Chattel Mortgage Because of Bank’s Fraud.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.