Montana Supreme Court December 9, 1925, No. 5,798. (State v. McDaniels)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-12-1925

*64

MR. JUSTICE STARK

delivered the opinion of the court.

The undisputed evidence in this case shows that on May 11, 1925, at the Gem rooming-house in Billings, officers, without having- a warrant therefor, placed the defendant under arrest. As they did so, a bindle, or package, of opium containing about ten grains, fell on the floor at defendant’s feet. This bindle either accidentally fell from the defendant’s pocket or he voluntarily threw it away. How it got to the floor from defendant’s person is immaterial on this appeal. It was immediately picked up by the officers, who declared in defendant’s presence: “Here it is; here’s the stuff.” The defendant, having been asked where he obtained the package, said he got it “from a Chinaman,” and that “he was going to smoke it.”

Two days later, on May 13, the county attorney filed an information in the district court charging that the defendant, on or about May 11, 1925, unlawfully,

etc.,

had “in his possession and under his control certain narcotic drugs, to-wit, approximately ten grains of opium. * * * ”

Defendant was placed on trial' on May 25, 1925. After making necessary preliminary proof, the state offered in evidence as its Exhibit “A” the bindle of opium which had been picked up at defendant’s feet as above recited. To this offer counsel for defendant objected on the ground that Exhibit “A” had been unlawfully and illegally obtained, “for the reason that the defendant was not lawfully under arrest before this package was found on the floor or before he dropped it, if he did drop it.” This objection was sustained by the court, whereupon the state, having no further evidence of the possession of narcotics by defendant, rested its case. Upon motion of counsel for defendant, the court directed the jury to return a verdict of not guilty, which was

*65

accordingly done. The state has appealed from this order .

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.