New York Court of Appeals February 25, 1925 (Kirby v. Newman)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-02-1925

Lehman, J.

The defendant is the owner of a house in the city of New York containing a store on the street level, an apartment above the store and a cellar below the store. The defendant occupied the apartment and leased the store to a tenant. The cellar was not leased to the tenant, but the tenant received the right to use it

“

in part

”

for storage. A flight of steps led from the sidewalk to the cellar. Doors were constructed which when closed covered the entrance to the steps in the sidewalk. On September 7, 1921, the doors were left open and the plaintiff Hannah M. Kirby while walking along the street fell down the steps into the cellar and sustained some injuries. She and her husband brought actions against this defendant claiming that as owner of the premises and in control of the door covering the steps to the cellar, the defendant is responsible for any damages caused by failure to keep the entrance to the cellar covered or to guard it when uncovered. The two actions were tried together, and the jury brought in verdicts in favor of the plaintiffs which the trial justice set aside.

*473

The complaints are based upon the defendant’s negligence, and without proof of defendant’s negligence there may be no recovery. We may assume that Mrs. Kirby was free from contributory negligence, .we may assume that some person was negligent in leaving open doors which are intended to cover an opening of the street, and in failing to guard the opening while it was uncovered. The question still remains whether such negligence is in law negligence of the defendant.

The evidence shows that on the morning of the accident there was some trouble in the electric lights in the store leased to the tenant. The tenant apparently did not complain to the defendant from whom he had leased the store- but to the builder of the house who had sold it to the defendant only a few- weeks earlier. The builder instructed an electrical contractor to repair the lights.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.