Supreme Court of North Carolina September 23, 1925 (State v. . Griffin)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-09-1925

Adams, J.

Pending the appeal, and immediately before the argument, the defendant filed a written motion for a new trial on the ground of newly discovered evidence. The motion, of course, must be denied. In

S. v. Lilliston,

141 N. C., 857, it is said that because the Court has no jurisdiction it has never entertained a motion of this kind, and that by uniformity of practice and decision the point has been definitely settled against the defendant’s present contention. There are many cases to this effect.

S. v. Flood, post (per

curiam);

S. v. Hartsfield,

188 N. C., 357;

S. v. Williams,

185 N. C., 643, 664;

S. v. Jenkins,

182 N. C., 818;

S. v. Ice Co.,

166 N. C., 403;

S. v. Arthur,

151 N. C., 653;

S. v. Turner,

143 N. C., 641;

S. v. Register,

133 N. C., 747;

S. v. Council,

129 N. C., 511;

S. v. Edwards,

126 N. C., 1051;

S. v. Rowe,

98 N. C., 629;

S. v. Starnes,

97 N. C., 423;

S.

c., 94 N. C., 973.

In reference to the exception’s concerning the admission of evidence, it is to be noted that this Court has frequently approved the withdrawal of incompetent testimony and the judge’s direction to the jury not to consider it. “It is undoubtedly proper and in the power of the court to correct a slip by withdrawing improper evidence from the consideration of the jury or by giving such explanation of an error as will prevent it from misleading a

jury”

— Ruffin,,

C. J.,

in

McAllister v. McAllister,

34 N. C., 184. See, also, additional citations in

S. v. Stewart,

*136

189 N. C., 340. But in the case before us tbe learned judge did not admit incompetent evidence; if there was inadvertence or error, it was that of the witness. His Honor was alert and vigilant to see that any remark prejudicial to the defendant or even susceptible of misconstruction should not be considered by the jury.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.