Court of Criminal Appeals of Oklahoma February 12, 1925, No. A-4855. (Shaver v. State)
Also known as
United States · · · 12-02-1925
DOYLE, J.
The information in this case charged
*166
that the defendant, J. E. Shaver, did unlawfully sell one-half pint of corn whisky to one Albert Thorlton. Upon his trial the jury returned a verdict finding him guilty and assessed his punishment at confinement in the county jail for 30 days and a fine of $50. From the judgment rendered on the verdict he appeals.
We adopt the confession of error as the opinion of the court. It is as follows:
“Numerous assignments of error are presented by counsel for plaintiff in error in their behalf; the first one being the introduction of incompetent, immaterial, and irrelevant testimony over the objections of the plaintiff in error by defendant in error.
“The second assignment of error complains of the action of the court in making certain remarks in the presence of the jury concerning the attorney for plaintiff in error and his actions and then refusing to restate the remarks to the court reporter in order to get them in the record and thereby enable counsel to take his exceptions and make his record.
“The other assignments of error all go to the introduction of incompetent, irrelevant, and immaterial testimony at different stages of the trial.
“We have read this record very carefully, and then for fear that we might be mistaken, we have read it the second time, and while this statement could not be literally true, yet there is scarcely a page of the record that does not disclose the rankest kind of prejudicial error. The trial was a farce, and the bulk of the .testimony introduced by the state tended only to prove or to attempt to prove that the plaintiff in error’s wife, who was not on trial, had in her possession half a pint of Canadian Club whisky with the unlawful intent to sell or dispose of same in violation of the law.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit