Supreme Court of Oklahoma November 10, 1925, 15424 (St. Louis & S. F. Ry. Co. v. Hartless)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-11-1925
Opinion by
LOGSDON, O.
On the merits of this case defendant urges but one proposition in its brief, viz., that no actionable negli
*39
gencte was .^hown. This contention was raised in the trial court at every stage of the proceedings. First, by demurrer to the petition; second, by objection to the introduction oif evidence; .third, by demurrer to the evidence; fourth, by motion for a directed verdict; fifth, by motion for a new trial specifically assigning as e,rror the action of the trial court in each of the particulars above enumerated.
Upon the trial plaintiff's testimony developed facts in substantial accord with the allegations of his petition. It was further shown that plaintiff had been engaged in similar railroad work since. 1904, and was an experienced man in the handling and use of wrenches. After the injury he signed a written statement in ■which he stated that the wrench be was using at the time of the injury was his personal property, and that there was nothing wrong with the wrench, only it was a little too short. On the witness stand plaintiff repudiated this portion of his signed statement, but confirmed it in all other respects. The wrench was not produced on the trial.
From the pleadings and facts heretofore abstracted, it is clearly apparent that the question raised and presented in the trial court by the various demurrers and motions was one of law as to the existence of primary negligence. It is elementary that in an action by an employe against his employer, the fact of accident and resulting injury raises no presumption of primary negligence on the part of the employer, but such negligence is an affirmative fact necessary to be shown by the allegations of the petition and to be established by the evidence. Unless this essential prerequisite to the right of recovery is made to appear, no case is made for submission to a jury.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit