Supreme Court of Oklahoma December 22, 1925, 16053 (Childers v. New York Life Ins. Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-12-1925

Opinion by

JONES, C.

This action was instituted in the district court of Pottawat-fomie county, Okla.. by' the appellant, as plaintiff, against appellee, as defendant, to recover $2,000, alleged damages by reason of the failure and neglect of defendant, New York Life Insurance Company, to deliver within a reasonable time a certain life insurance policy. Motion for judgment on the pleadings was interposed by defendant, which was by the court sustained upon the theory that the defendant, insurance company, had, under the termq'of the application for insurance, 60 days in which to act in the matter, and plaintiff's petition shows that the policy was issued within that period.

The facts, as disclosed by the record, show that the deceased, F(v'ed Ira Childers, made application through the local agent of the defendant company for insurance on February 24, 1923, and submitted to medical examination on February 26th: that the application and medical examination reached the office of the defendant company in New York City on March 12th, and that the policy was issued March 13, 1923, and reached the local agent at Norman, Okla., on March 19, 1923. The applicant was accidentally killed March 16th, and plaintiff alleges in her petition that the company was guilty of negligence and did not issue and deliver the policy within a reasonable time.

The only question involved in this appeal is the action of the court in sustaining the motion for judgment on the pleadings, and dismissing with prejudice plaintiff’s cause of action. The provision of the contract of insurance upon which the judgment of the court was based and upon which the appel-lee relies, is found in the receipt issued by the soliciting agent to the applicant on payment of the premium at the time the application was made, and is as follows :

“(a) If the company fails lo offer to deliver a policy within 60 days from this date, the company will return said sum to the applicant upon demand with surrender of ibis receipt.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.