Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas May 20, 1925, No. 9113. (Franks v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-05-1925

BERRY Judge.

Appellant was convicted in the district court of Randall County 'for the offense of transporting intoxicating liquor, and his punishment assessed at confinement in the penitentiary for one year.

The state introduced three witnesses in making its cases and the appellant introduced none, and neither did he take the stand in his own behalf. The evidence as it appears to this court is rather meagre and unsatisfactory, and we are disposed to think the jury viewed it in the same light, as the record shows that the testimony was in no wise conflicting, yet the jury deliberated on the same for something like twenty hours. In this condition of the record, we have felt disposed to give special attention to appellant’s complaint at the misconduct of the jury.

By a proper bill of exception, appellant complains that the jury discussed his failure to testify. This bill embodies within it the testimony of six of the jurors who tried the ease. The testimony of these jurors is undisputed to the effect that defendant’s failure to take the stand and testify in his own behalf was discussed at least two or three times during the deliberation of the jury and before a verdict had been reached. The following from the juror Gregg is characteristic of the testimony on this question: “One question brought on another and someone asked if he wasn’t guilty why didn’t he produce evidence proving that he wasn’t guilty?” “The fact that he didn’t take the stand was discussed some three times, I will say, during our deliberations.” “I am certain I am safe in saying that occurred three times during the deliberations.” Each of the six jurors who testified practically agreed concerning this matter. It was also in evidence that the foreman sought to suppress this discussion but it is certain that he was unable to suppress it until it had been brought up in various ways at least three times.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.