Washington Supreme Court November 24, 1925, No. 19166. En Banc. (Thosath v. Transport Motor Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 24-11-1925
lead-opinion
Holcomb, J.
— This action is to recover the sum of $240, paid by Perry Thosath, a minor, as a first pay
*566
ment on the purchase price of a second hand automobile, purchased by him from appellant under a conditional bill of sale. He asked judgment, also, for repairs alleged to have been placed upon the automobile while in his possession, amounting to $117.75. On a trial to a jury, a verdict was returned for $269. The trial judge reduced the recovery to $240, and rendered judgment therefor. Motions for judgment n. o. v., and in the alternative for a new trial, were overruled.
In the complaint, respondent relied both upon deceit and false representations as to the value and condition of the automobile when sold, and the voidability of the contract on account of the minority of the purchaser; .but, on submitting the case to the jury, the trial judge held that respondent could not rely upon both grounds of rescission, and required respondent to elect. Respondent then elected to stand upon the minority of the purchaser, upon which the case was submitted to the jury on that issue alone, of which respondent does not complain.
In submitting the case to the jury the trial judge, among others, gave the following instruction:
“And in order to determine whether defendant’s agent had good reasons to believe that the minor was capable of contracting at the time, you should also take into consideration the appearance of the minor at the time of entering into this contract, and any and all other circumstances which surrounded the making of the contract at the time in question, in order to determine that question of fact.”
The record shows that a contract was first entered into between the minor and appellant on May 24,1924, for the exchange of an Oakland- sedan car, owned, as the minor said, by himself and his brother, which had not been fully paid for by them to the Eldridge-Buick
*567
Company of Spokane, from whom they had bought it.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit