Washington Supreme Court March 6, 1925, No. 18956. Department Two. (Schmitz v. Mathews)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-03-1925

Mackintosh, J.

Respondent’s complaint alleged that he advanced $600 to the appellant, which the appellant has failed to repay. The appellant’s answer denied that the $600 was advanced as a loan, and, as an affirmative answer, alleged it was given as part payment of the purchase price of stock owned by appellant, and that respondent had failed and refused to pay the balance of the purchase price. The answer did not ask for any affirmative relief, but merely that respondent ’s action be dismissed. The only alleged error which we are called upon to consider arises from the giving of two instructions to the jury.

*336

One of these was to the effect that, if the jury believed that the evidence was evenly balanced as to whether the agreement was as alleged by respondent or as claimed by appellant, the verdict should be for appellant, as respondent had the burden of proving the allegations of his complaint by a fair preponderance of the evidence. The other instruction was that the burden of proof was on the appellant to support by a fair preponderance of the evidence the allegations contained in his affirmative defense, and that, if appellant had failed to prove these material allegations, it would be the jury’s duty to find for the respondent.

These instructions are concededly conflicting and contradictory and must have been confusing to the jury. The burden of proof is not upon a defendant to prove any allegations of his affirmative defense when the affirmative defense, as here, adds nothing to the general denial and raises no affirmative issues. When such instructions are found, the error is prejudicial. See

Fireman’s Fund Insurance Co. v. Oregon-Washington R. & Nav. Co.,

96 Wash. 113, 164 Pac. 765, where many cases from this court are cited.

The respondent argues, however, that the appellant is in no position to complain of the instructions, for the error, which it is tacitly conceded exists, was one which the respondent asserts was invited by the appellant.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.