Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas January 7, 1925, No. 9114 (Ex parte McNeely)
Also known as
United States · · · 07-01-1925
LATTIMORE, J.
This is an appeal from an order of the district court of Bell county denying bail. Appellant was charged with. murder.. We are asked to affirm the judgment. In order to do so we must be led to believe that upon a trial before a fair jury a death sentence would be inflicted. The men were brothers-in-law, and appellant is shown to have been dissatisfied with a division of land, and to have had a grudge against deceased. They were seen talking in front of a store. Appellant was angry. In a short time the homicide occurred. One witness said he saw deceased ward off a blow and strike appellant, staggering him back. Blood began to flow down the face of appellant, and he came back preparing to shoot, and did shoot four times. What was said or done precipitating the first blow is not shown *718in the record. Several witnesses speak of seeing the parties “scuffling” before the shooting began. What brought about the scuffle is not shown in the record. The blow inflicted upon appellant by deceased which preceded the shooting-cut through a heavy hat and to the bone above appellant’s eye. A piece of iron was found on the person of deceased, and a physician testified that this instrument apparently could have caused the injury inflicted upon appellant. We are left in the dark as to what passed between the two men before they began scuffling, or what immediately caused or led up to the first blow which was apparently struck by appellant. He may have intended merely a fist ■fight. He may not have had his pistol out when he’ struck at deceased. He may have intended by an assault with his fist to provoke an attack on the part of deceased which could be used as a pretext for wreaking his malice upon the latter.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit