Texas Commission of Appeals October 14, 1925, No. 521-4199 (Thomason v. Berry)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-10-1925

SPEER, J.

G. W. Thomason and Y. D. Thomason sued the Boggy Valley Oil Company, a corporation, A. V. De Pascale, W. L. Berry, and Calvin J. Henson to recover a balance claimed as rent on certain well-drilling machinery and implements, and also for the value of such machinery and implements, alleging that the defendants had failed to return the same, but had converted it to their own use.

The action was based upon a written contract. The defendants Berry and Henson answered, denying that they were personally liable on the contract, and alleging for reasons stated that the contract was that of the Boggy Valley Oil Company,, these defendants being vice president and secretary, respectively, of that corporation. There was a judgment by default as against the corporation, and a judgment in favor of the defendant De Pas-cale, and a judgment upon verdict against the defendants Berry and Henson individually, which judgment, in the last respect, was reversed by the Court of Civil Appeals (261 S: W. 154), andi the cause is now before us upon writ of esror to review that judgment.

The Court of Civil Appeals reversed the judgment of the trial court for its refusal to submit certain requested issues of fact touching the individual liability of the defendants Berry and Henson, upon the theory that the instrument sued on did not clearly *186import the individual liability of these defendants, but that it was ambiguous, permitting the defense that it was not intended to bind the defendants Berry and Henson individually. The plaintiffs, however, sued these defendants individually, alleging that the contract was theirs; and, while these defendants denied individual liability thereon, such answer was not verified as required by article 1906, Vernon’s Sayles’' Civil Statutes. The answer of these defendants was in effect a plea of non est factum, but, as stated, lacked the verification required by statute.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.