Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York January 7, 1925 (Moir v. Johnson)
Also known as
United States · · · 07-01-1925
Crouch, J.:
Defendant Johnson under date of September 25, 1923, made two promissory notes to his own order, each for $6,000, indorsed them in blank and delivered them to one Evans. Evans transferred them to the defendant Curtiss, who indorsed them in blank and transferred them to the plaintiff.
Plaintiff brings this action on the notes. The complaint is in the usual form, but fails to allege that the notes were delivered to plaintiff before maturity. The answer of Johnson admits the making and indorsement in blank, denies all other allegations and sets up various defenses which, among others, in effect charge that plaintiff is not a holder in due course because he took the notes after maturity in bad faith and with notice of a defect in the title.
Plaintiff resides in Onondaga county, where the action is brought. Defendant Johnson resides in Nassau county. Defendant Curtiss resides or has his place of business in New York city. The notes were dated at New York but were made and were payable at East Norwich, in Nassau county.
Plaintiff moved for summary judgment against defendant Johnson under rule 113 of the Rules of Civil Practice. Johnson made a cross motion to change the venue from Onondaga county to Nassau county for the convenience of witnesses. The motions were brought on together and under stipulation the papers were used and considered interchangeably on both. The motion for -judgment was granted and hence the other was denied.
We think both orders should be reversed.
1. The remedy under rule 113 is useful but drastic. It should be applied only where it is perfectly plain that there is no substantial issue to be tried. (Peninsular T. Co., Inc., v. Greater B. Ins. Corp., Ltd., 200 App. Div. 695, 701; King Motor Sales Corp. v. Allen, 209 id. 281.)
On the affidavits before the court there is practically no dispute that Evans procured the notes from Johnson by fraud and wrongfully negotiated them.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit