Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York April 3, 1925 (Bender v. Benenson Realty Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-04-1925

lead-opinion

Martin, J.:

This action was brought by plaintiff, an experienced real estate broker, to recover $3,447.50 alleged to be due from defendant as commissions for services upon the exchange of properties. The complaint alleges the contract, the performance of services thereunder, and their reasonable value in the sum of $3,947.50, for which amount, less $500, alleged to have been received on account, judgment is demanded. The answer denies the contract alleged and sets forth, as the only contract between the parties, an express agreement in writing whereby plaintiff agreed to accept in full for his services as such broker the sum of $500, it being alleged that the $500 was paid [to plaintiff in full for his services and was by him “ accepted in full for his brokerage fees upon said sale.”

There is no dispute that plaintiff performed services as broker in bringing about an exchange of properties, including, property owned by defendant. The difference between the parties is with reference to the amount of the commission plaintiff became entitled to receive, defendant’s contention being that he is limited by his special agreement to the sum of $500 in full for his services, and •is concluded by his acceptance of that amount in full settlement of his claim.

Plaintiff’s testimony is to the effect that after the terms were arranged and agreed upon, the representative of defendant required him to agree in writing that the commission would be $500, instead of the much larger amount alleged in the complaint; that he objected *480to this, but rather than see the deal fall through, he finally agreed to take the $500 and signed a writing which reads:

“ Benenson Realty Co. : June 28 /20.

“ Gentlemen.— To induce you to enter into a contract of exchange between yourselves and my client, Mr. J. Greenberg for the properties No.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.