Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York October 30, 1925 (Gentilala v. Fay Taxicabs, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 30-10-1925
Finch, J.:
This is an action for damages for personal injuries, brought on behalf of an infant who was struck by a taxicab owned by the defendant.
The issues of fact arising have been submitted to a jury, and no sufficient reason is presented for disturbing their verdict thereon. There is, however, presented as an additional ground of appeal a question of law which requires the reversal of the judgment.
The facts, in so far as necessary to determine this question of law, are, briefly, as follows: The defendant in its answer by way of defense alleged that there was another action pending between the same parties upon the same cause of action. The case was duly noticed for trial, and upon the trial the facts showed that an action had previously been commenced by a firm of attorneys other than those representing the plaintiff in this action. The defendant moved for judgment on that ground. The attorneys for the plaintiff in the other pending action then moved, during the trial and in this action, to discontinue the other action, and that motion was granted. After the verdict, however, the court *257reopened the proceedings, stating: “ Upon my own motion, I reopen the proceedings and deny plaintiff’s application to discontinue the action brought by Hartman & Levy in behalf of Patsy Gentilala, an infant plaintiff, v. Fay Taxicabs, Inc. The motion of defendant to dismiss the complaint because of the existence of a prior action and defendant’s motion to withdraw a juror and declare a mistrial are denied. As defendant never moved against the complaint on Civil Practice Rule 107, he is now by section 278 of the Civil Practice Act, held to have waived his objection that another action was pending between the parties for the cause.”
In thus holding that rule 107 was mandatory, the learned trial justice was in error.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit