Court of Appeals of Georgia February 12, 1925, 15631 (Ryle v. Farmers & Merchants Bank)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-02-1925

Jenkins, P. J.

(After stating the foregoing facts.)

1. “If the fact of suretyship does not appear on the face of the contract, it may be proved by parol either before or after the judgment (the creditor not being delayed in his remedy by such collateral issue between the principal and his surety), if before judgment the surety shall give notice to the principal of his intention to make such proof.” Civil Code (1910), § 3556. The record shows that notice of such intention was given to the principal in the instant case. If such a surety “is by an erroneous ruling denied the right to establish before judgment the fact thus set up, he is entitled *462to a new trial.” Whitley v. Hudson, 114 Ga. 668 (3) (40 S. E. 838). In the case here cited the alleged error was the exclusion of evidence seeking to show that the defendant had signed merely as surety. In the instant case no such evidence was excluded; but it is contended that the court erred in charging generally that, “in the event you find for the defendant, the form of your verdict would be, cWe, the jury, find for the defendant/ and in failing in the same connection to charge the jury that if they found that she was surety only, the form of their verdict would be that they found that she was surety on the note, and that the plaintiff have judgment against her as surety in the sum sued for.” Even if the failure so to charge, in the absence of a written request, might be accounted error, it was, under the particular facts, without injury to this defendant; since it appears that after the other defendant, the alleged principal, had sustained his plea of discharge in bankruptcy, the court directed a verdict in his favor.

2.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.