Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Philadelphia County March 30, 1925, No. 1086 (Blumenthal v. Rosenblatt & Blum Bros.)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-03-1925

Lewis, J.,

Claimant, wife of one of the defendants in the execution, has taken this rule for leave to file her own bond in an interpleader. The goods levied upon as the property of her husband and his partner include certain household furniture, which was located in a residence owned by the claimant wife and occupied by her. The wife avers that the goods to which she makes claim were, at the time of the levy, her sole and absolute property, that she did not derive title to same, directly or indirectly, from her husband or his co-defendant, and that the goods were also in her exclusive possession on the day of the levy. By stipulation, it has been agreed, however, that the defendant husband and the claimant wife were residing together at the time of the levy, occupying the premises in which the household goods were located. Presumably, the personal property was in every-day use by the members of the family, including the husband, but it appears that the wife acquired ownership thereof prior to her marriage, either by purchase with her own funds or by gift from persons other than the defendants in the execution.

The question is, when husband and wife are living together in a home owned by the wife, can there be in the wife an exclusive possession of household furniture contained in the family residence? Can the wife, while living with her husband, have possession exclusive of him? It is conceded that if this question is answered in the affirmative, leave should be granted to the claimant to file her own bond as prayed for.

We have reviewed the prior decisions, including those of this court, and are persuaded that, in the light of present-day conditions, the conclusion reached by Judge Stewart in Hochman v. Carroll, 19 Dist. R. 243, is sound and should be followed. The circumstances were strikingly similar to the case at bar, the wife therein having been the proprietress of a boarding-house conducted on premises occupied also by her husband and herself.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.