Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Philadelphia County May 13, 1925, No. 926, M. L. D. (City of Philadelphia ex rel. McHugh v. Morone)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-05-1925

Taulane, J.,

This matter comes before the court on a demurrer to a municipal claim and the scire facias issued thereon. The defendant entered a motion to strike off the claim- for defects appearing on the face of the claim, to which the plaintiff filed an answer. The motion was dismissed and the plaintiff then issued a scire facias, to which a demurrer has been filed.

As the motion to strike off the claim was based on defects in the claim itself, no answer should have been filed, and the answer filed has no proper place in the record. Issues of fact cannot be raised by an answer to a petition to strike off a claim for defects appearing on the face of the claim.

Instead of ordering the demurrer on the list for argument, the plaintiff entered a rule for judgment for want of a sufficient affidavit of defence, which has been withdrawn. The demurrer is now before the court for decision.

There is no doubt a defendant may demur, instead of filing an affidavit of defence, to a scire facias sur municipal claim: Lehman v. Thomas, 5 W. & S. 262; Hill v. McDowell, 14 Pa. 175, and City of York v. Miller, 254 Pa. 436.

*127Indeed, defects appearing on the face of a claim can only be taken advantage of by a motion to strike off or a demurrer; filing an affidavit of defence to the merits is a waiver of such defects: Scholl v. Gerhab, 93 Pa. 346.

There is nothing in the Act of June 4, 1901, P. L. 364, regulating the filing and enforcing of municipal claims, which changes the practice of demurring to municipal claims: City of York v. Miller, 254 Pa. 436.

The grounds of the demurrer are substantially the same as the reasons set forth in the petition to strike off the claim.

The plaintiff contends that the dismissal of the motion to strike off is res judicata,, and that the defects in the claim relied upon in the motion to strike off cannot again be objected to by demurrer. This contention cannot be sustained.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.