Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit March 2, 1925, No. 4156 (R. Harris & Co. v. Weller)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-03-1925

MARTIN, Chief Justice.

R. Harris & Co., a corporation, brought an action in the lower court against Joseph I. Weller, claiming that it had employed him to act as its agent in the purchase of certain real estate situate within the District of Columbia, and had paid him the sum of $10,000 as commissions for his .services as such agent, whereas at the same time, without its knowledge or consent, he was also receiving compensation from the vendor of the property for services rendered as his agent in the same transaction. Wherefore the plaintiff prayed for a recovery against him in the sum of $10,000.

In defense of the action the defendant denied that he had acted ás agent for the plaintiff in the transaction, in question, and alleged furthermore that the issue in the present case is identical with one which was formerly adjudicated adversely to the plaintiff by the Supreme Court of the District in a ease between the same parties. It may be stated here that the decree thus pleaded as a former adjudication of the issue was affirmed by this court upon appeal in R. Harris & Co. v. Weller et al., 52 App. D. C. 6, 280 P. 980. The opinion in that ease, written by Mr. Justice Robb, so fully presents the facts and circumstances of the transaction in question that it becomes unnecessary to go into great detail here.

The issue in the present ease went to trial before the court and jury, and at the close of the plaintiff’s evidence a verdict was directed in favor of the defendant. Judgment was entered accordingly, whereupon the plaintiff appealed.

Several witnesses testified in behalf of the ^plaintiff at the trial. Their testimony contained substantial contradictions and inconsistencies, but for the present; purpose the evidence must be given the most favorable construction which it may bear in favor of the plaintiff’s claim.. This is to be drawn almost entirely from the testimony of Mr.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.