Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit April 6, 1925, No. 4239 (Egan v. United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-04-1925

ROBB, Associate Justice.

This is an appeal from a judgment of conviction in the Supreme Court of the District of Columbia under an indictment charging the defendant, appellant here, with a violation of sections 113 and 117 of the Penal Code of the United States (35 Stat. 1088, 1109 [Comp. St. §§ 10283, 10287]). This is the second trial under the same indictment, a former conviction having been set aside by this court. See Egan v. United States, 52 App. D. C. 384, 287 F. 958.

The first question presented by this appeal is based upon the contention that two distinct and inconsistent offenses were charged in the indictment and that the trial court erred in accepting a general verdict of guilty. In our prior opinion it was ruled that, since the crimes defined in the two sections belonged to the same class and might be separately charged in a single indictment, a general verdict of guilty on all counts would be sustained if any count was good and sufficient to support the judgment. The question was there raised by motion to require the district attorney to elect upon which counts of the indictment he would go to trial.

We said:

“This motion was based upon the theory that the indictment included two separate offenses under the Penal Code. This is permissible, and election will not be required, where the offenses charged are not distinct and inconsistent. The crimes defined in sections 113 and 117 belong to the same class, and may.be separately charged in a single indictment. In such a case a general verdict of guilty on all the counts will be sustained in error, if any count is good and sufficient to support the judgment. Claassen v. United States, 142 U. S. 140, 12 S. Ct. 169, 35 L. Ed. 966; Evans v. United States, 153 U. S. 584, 14 S. Ct. 934, 38 L. Ed. 830; Davis v. United States, 37 App. D. C. 126, 133.”

. It thus appears that it was distinctly ruled that the crimes denounced in these two sections are not inconsistent.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.