Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit May 21, 1925, No. 4477 (McParland-Scanlon Lumber Co. v. J. J. Newman Lumber Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 21-05-1925
FOSTER, Circuit Judge.
In this ease the record is somewhat unsatisfactory and it is difficult to determine exactly what errors are relied upon for reversal, because of the failure to follow rule 11 of this court, whieh requires that, when error is alleged to the admission or rejection of evidence, the assignment of errors shall quote the full substance of the evidence admitted or rejected, and when error is alleged to the charge of the court the assignment of errors shall set out the part referred to totidem verbis. The issues presented to this court may be best understood by a brief statement of the ease as appearing from the pleadings and the evidence in the record.
Referring to the parties as they appeared in the District Court, it appears that plaintiff, the J. J. Newman Lumber Company, sold to the Baldwin Lumber Company some 500,000 feet of hardwood lumber, consisting of poplar, oak, and gum, at prices, respectively, of $72.50, $50, and $42.50 per 1,000 The contract was made May 10, 1920, and is in the simple form of an order, calling for delivery at once, 'payment to be in cash, less 2 per cent, discount. Subsequently, and before the entry of this suit, the Baldwin Lumber Company changed its name by amendment of its charter to the MeParland-Sean-lon Lumber Company; the corporation, however, remaining the same. Plaintiff has mills at Hattiesburg and Sumrall, Miss., The greater portion of the lumber had already been manufactured, and was piled on the yards at these mills. The balance was to be manufactured in the course of the delivery. It was in contemplation of the parties that defendant would send its inspectors to one or the other of the mills and there take up and receive delivery of the lumber in carload lots, each carload to be invoiced at delivery, and payment to be made within 15 days. No lumber was taken up between September-, 1920, and December 1, 1921, at which time all the lumber covered by the contract had been manufactured and piled.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit