District Court, D. Minnesota August 6, 1925 (Leverentz v. Chicago, M. & St. P. Ry. Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-08-1925

CANT, District Judge.

To justify the remanding of this case, the allegations of the complaint should show with at least reasonable clearness that a cause of action is set forth against the local defendant. That should not be entirely lacking, nor left to be spelled ont from vague, uncertain, or equivocal statements in the pleadings.

In that connection the allegations here are that the defendant Oatman was head brakeman on the train in question, and that “at the time of said accident (he) was charged with the duty of maintaining or keeping a lookout for persons using said Cleveland avenue at said crossing.” Paragraph III of the complaint. In paragraph IV of the complaint the allegations are that at the time in question, “the defendants * * * carelessly, negligently, and unlawfully operated said train at a high and unreasonable rate of speed under the circumstances in approaching and crossing said Cleveland avenue, and at a speed prohibited by the ordinances of the City of. St. Paul, carelessly, negligently, and unlawfully failed to give said Carl Edward Leverentz proper or adequate warning of the approach of said train under all the circumstances, or to keep a lookout upon said train in approaching and crossing said Cleveland avenue, and carelessly and negligently failed to adequately and properly safeguard said crossing and warn the said Carl Edward Leverentz and others’ and the publie generally of the approach of trains.”

In connection with the operation of the train it does not appear that the defendant Oatman had any duties to perform at the time in question, exeept to keep a lookout. He was a brakeman only, and his duties were strictly limited. To allege, as plaintiff does, that the defendants (using the plural) carelessly, etc., operated said train, when taken in connection with the other allegations, and with common knowledge as to how trains are operated, is, as against the defendant Oat-*397man, mere words.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.