District Court, N.D. Ohio June 24, 1925, No. 971 (Pashek v. Dunlop Tyre & Rubber Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 24-06-1925
WESTENHAVER, District Judge.
The bill is based on and charges infringement of design patent No. 52,962, issued February 4. 1919, to plaintiff. The patent is for an ornamental design for an automobile tire. The ornamentation is applied to the tread surface. It consists of a central circumferential strap or ridge, continuous grooves on each side thereof, except as broken by lugs connecting the central strap with the skid pads, and a series of skid pads on each side of said grooves, with rearwardly inclined grooves or openings between the pads. Each pad is connected with the circumferential ridge by a narrow lug, some times called a flow bar, from the function performed by it during the process of molding the tire..
Defendant’s tire is likewise covered by a design patent, 62,172, issued to Wallace Henry Pauli April 3, 1923, on application filed July 25, 1921. The two designs are almost identical. There are minor differences in the shape of the skid pads and in the lugs or flow bars. In plaintiff’s design, the flow bar is of substantial width and strength, whereas defendant has striven to eliminate the flow bar as far as it can be done, while permitting it to perform the required function during the process of manufacture. It is much narrower and less .substantial. It is defendant’s claim that this flow bar is a disadvantage in a finished tire, and would be removed before the tire is sold, except for the expense of the additional operation. In use it is said to break down and disappear soon after the tire is put in use, so that the circumferential grooves are practically continuous. Despite these differences, however, I am of opinion, if plaintiff’s design patent is valid, infringement is fully established.
No question of 'unfair competition enters into this case. Tires were manufactured embodying plaintiff’s design during a period of some two years between 1917 and the earlier part of 1920.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit