Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit November 17, 1925, No. 7016 (Glenn v. W. C. Mitchell Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-11-1925

LEWIS, Circuit Judge.

This is an appeal from a dismissal of appellant’s bill on final hearing, wherein he asked the court to vacate and set aside a sale under execution made by the Marshal of a grain elevator at Merricourt, N. D. The execution was issued on a judgment obtained by appellee for a partnership debt of Glenn & Hafey, against appellant as surviving partner of the firm. See Glenn v. W. C. Mitchell Co. (C. C. A.) 282 F. 440; Id. (C. C. A.). 285 F. 381. The attack made on the sa-lei is, first, that the elevator was advertised as personal property, whereas it was a chattel real, having been constructed under a ground lease, and under the State statute regulating the subject it should have been advertised and sold as real estate, thus giving the judgment debtor a period for redemption; secondly, that the partnership and Glenn as surviving partner was lessee of the ground on which the elevator stood and that the elevator and leasehold interest constituted, a chattel real, that the elevator and lease should have been sold together as one and to sell them separately was destructive of the value of each; and thirdly, the Marshal made statements at the sale which prevented free competitive bidding. As to the first point, the State statute relied on defines estates for years as chattels real, and requires that they be sold on execution as real estate. The facts bearing on the objections raised will be stated.

The elevator was constructed on the right of way of the Soo Railway Company, under a written agreement between that company and the Powers Elevator Company, of dato June 1, 1917. It is the usual contract made by railway companies in such cases. It is termed a lease, it described the ground on which the elevator was constructed, and .

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.