District Court, S.D. New York December 30, 1925 (The City of Dunkirk)

WINSLOW, District Judge.

This action is brought to recover for short delivery and damage on a shipment of cocoanut oil carried on the steamship City of Dunkirk from Manila, to the city of New York, October, 1920, to January, 1921, and to recover special expenses incurred by the libelant by reason of delivery of a portion of the oil in a damaged condition and in part solidified.