Court of Appeals of Kentucky March 13, 1925 (Williams v. Commonwealth)
Also known as
United States · · · 13-03-1925
*808Opinion of the Court by
Chief Justice Settle—
Reversing.
The appellant, G-eorge Williams, was indicted in the court below for the offense of unlawfully aud knowingly selling to Amanda Jane Partou, for beverage purposes, “A liquid mixture and medicinal preparation known . . . as 'Batesman’s drops,’ which contained more than one-half of one per cent by volume of alcohol, same being an intoxicant. ’ ’ His trial by jury under the indictment, resulted in a verdict finding him guilty and fixing his punishment at a fine of $150.00' and imprisonment of 45 days in jail. He has appealed from the judgment approving that verdict.
Two of the numerous grounds that were relied on Iby the appellant for the new trial refused him by the circuit court, are strongly urged by his counsel for the reversal of the judgment, viz., error alleged to have been committed by the trial court to the prejudice of his substantial rights: First, in overruling his motion, made at the conclusion of the evidence, for an instruction peremptorily directing the jury to return a verdict of “not guilty.” Second, misconduct of the presiding judge of the court toward the two panels of the jury and the appellant, before the beginning of the latter’s trial, amounting to a breach of official duty and abuse of judicial power.
The first of these contentions is rested upon the grounds: First, that the evidence failed to show a sale of the “Bateman’s drops” by the appellant within a year before the finding of the indictment; second, that it also failed to show that it was knowingly sold by the appellant for beverage purposes. We are unable to find that the record supports the contention upon either of the grounds urged. It is apparent from the evidence of Amanda Partou, purchaser of the Bateman’s drops, that she was a reluctant witness.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit