Louisiana Court of Appeal May 5, 1925 (Louisiana State Rice Milling Co. v. Hornsby)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-05-1925

MOUTON, J.

The appeal in this case was dismissed for the reasons given in our opinion which was rendered March 5, 1923. A rehearing was granted April 10, 1923.

In the brief of counsel for plaintiff company which accompanies the motion for a rehearing, we are referred to the case of Southern Timber and Land Company vs. Martel, 109 La. 453, 33 South. 559. In that case a demand was made against alleged trespassers of a large tract of land, but against each with respect to the subdivision of the tract which he was averred to be trespassing upon, and for the rents and revenues thereof. The court, in that case, said it "does not appear that the defendants trace title to a common author, that there is any privity or common interest between them, or that either will be affected by a judgment against the other”. The court held that its appellate jurisdiction depended upon theamount or value demanded from each defendant, which the record showed fell below its minimum jurisdiction. In the concluding part of our opinion dismissing the appeal for want of jurisdiction we said: “The issue herein, involving Hornsby as principal, Webb and Bergeron as sureties, are so intimately connected that one cannot be solved independently of the other. Having no jurisdiction over the claim against Hornshy, we have none over the demand against’ the sureties.” Here, as a result of our analysis of the case as expressed in our opinion. *585we found that Hornsby, the principal, and his sureties had a common, if not an identical, interest in the issues presented for solution.

The situation in the present case is quite different from that which appeared in the case above cited, wherein the court held that there was no privity or common interest between the parties defendant. A reexamination of this case has satisfied us that the opinion rendered by us March 5, 1923, is correct, for reasons therein stated, but which we find unnecessary to repeat in support of our conclusions herein.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.