Supreme Court of New Jersey October 6, 1925 (Corum v. Davis)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-10-1925

Per Curiam.

This is a suit by a married woman, her husband adding his claim per quod, for damages sustained by personal injuries due to an automobile collision. The facts, as developed on the trial, and which the jury might have found to be substantially, are that Mrs. Corum was a passenger in a Ford sedan, driven by one Jackson, at night. As this car was proceeding on its proper side of the road, it became necessary to pass a large auto bus coming in the other direction, and as these two vehicles neared each other, and were about to pass, the defendant Boa, driving his own car, shot out from behind the auto bus and collided with the Ford sedan.

Neither defendant appeared at the trial, although the plaintiff had subpoenaed both of them as witnesses, and there was no evidence submitted for the defendants except that of a medical expert, with respect to Mrs. Corum’s injuries. The plaintiff endeavored, unsuccessfully, to prove some connection of the defendant Davis with the affair, but the court granted *982a nonsuit so far as he was concerned, and let the jury take the case as against Boa. There was a verdict in favor of Mrs. Corum against Boa for $1,500, and in favor of her husband for $400.

We take up the points as made. One, that the verdicts were excessive. Mrs. Corum had a fractured patella, an injury which is never permanently healed because the fractured portions of the patella never form a bony union. At the trial she said that she still walked stiffly and had had a great deal of pain. It also appears that she was- accustomed to work out as a caterer, doing business on her own account, and that she had lost earnings in that line. We consider that the verdict of $1,500 in her favor, was entirely reasonable.

As to the verdict of $400 awarded in favor of the husband, it was shown that lie had had some expense for medical service, and that he had had to stay at home from work nursing his wife.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.