Wisconsin Supreme Court May 12, 1925 (Menasha Woodenware Co. v. Industrial Commission)
Also known as
United States · · · 12-05-1925
Crownhart, J.
There is only one serious question to be considered in this case. The husband of the respondent *22Mathilda Kuhr was employed as head fireman by the appellant corporation, and during the course of his employment he got into a pit of hot water in a portion of plaintiff’s pump house and was either drowned or scalded to death. The question to be determined is whether or not the deceased came to his death as the result of suicide or as the result of accident. The Industrial Commission found in favor of accident, and the findings of fact of the Industrial Commission, within its jurisdiction, in the absence of fraud, are conclusive.
No one saw the tragedy. The ultimate finding of fact of death turns wholly upon circumstantial evidence.
In the recent case of Fehrer v. Midland Cas. Co. 179 Wis. 431, 434, 190 N. W. 910, this court said:
“The law is well settled, based on human experience, that there is a strong presumption against suicide. The love of life and the immorality of taking one’s own life turn the mind against suicide. So it is that when suicide is alleged in defense the burden is on the defendant to establish such fact. In such a case, where the evidence is wholly circumstantial, as in this case, every other reasonable hypothesis to account for the death must be excluded to take the case from the jury.” Citing a number of cases.
The same presumption is indulged in under the workmen’s compensation law as in an action on an insurance policy. Milwaukee Western F. Co. v. Industrial Comm. 159 Wis. 635, 150 N. W. 998; Bekkedal L. Co. v. Industrial Comm. 168 Wis. 230, 169 N. W. 561.
The main facts in this case may be briefly stated. The deceased Kuhr had been employed by the plaintiff some thirty years and as head fireman eighteen or twenty years. On June 19, 1921, he came to his place of employment earlier than usual, at about 6:20. a. m. His time of beginning work was 7 o’clock. At 6:45 a. m.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit