Wisconsin Supreme Court May 12, 1925 (Isaacson v. Wisconsin Casualty Ass'n)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-05-1925

Vinje, C. J.

The defendant claims that a proper notice was not given to it and therefore it is not liable. The policy required that notice be given “To the company at Green Bay, Wisconsin, or to any authorized agent of the company *27at Green Bay, Wisconsin.” Sec. 208.05, sub. (3), par. (5) of the standard provision form of policy provides:

“(5) A standard provision relative to sufficiency of notice of claim which shall be in one of the following forms and in which the insurer shall insert in the blank space such office and its location as it may desire to designate for such purpose of notice:

“(A) : — (5) Such notice given by or in behalf of the insured or beneficiary, as the case may be, to the insurer at -, or to any authorized agent of the insurer, with particulars sufficient to identify the insured, shall be deemed to be notice to the insurer. ...”

“(B): — (5) The foregoing paragraph may be changed by inserting in lieu of the words ‘any authorized agent of the insurer’ the following: ‘-, agent of the insurer at •-,’ and by filling the blank before the word ‘agent’ with a designation or name of an agent, and by filling the blank after the word ‘at’ with a postoffice address, both to be sufficient to assure the delivery of mail to such agent.”

The claim is that the policy complied with the terms of the statute as to giving notice to an agent of the insurer at Green Bay, Wisconsin, and therefore the insured must comply with the method of notice designated in the policy. The alternative notice provided for in the policy differs from the alternative statutory form in that it does not designate the name of the agent at Green Bay to whom notice is to be given. Its failure so to do is material and renders the alternative provision of the policy void.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.