Wisconsin Supreme Court November 17, 1925 (Simonsen v. Froedtert Lumber Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 17-11-1925
Eschweiler, J.
Defendant contends, that the verdict in plaintiff’s favor should have been set aside as contrary to the great weig'ht of evidence; urging on this behalf the long delay of over two years after the rendition of the services before a claim for commission was made; the fact that plaintiff had expressed a willingness to leave the amount of compensation to be determined by Mr. Froedtert; that at one time $500 would have been an acceptable sum as compensation ; that plaintiff’s position as general manager, vice-president, and director of the defendant corporation establishes a presumption that the services were rendered by him as part of his duties to the company as such officer; the positive-denial by Mr. Froedtert of any special agreement; and that all of these should have overborne in the minds of an unprejudiced jury the positive testimony of the plaintiff that *203there was a special agreement between himself and Mr. Froedtert.
' A consideration of the testimony satisfies us, however, that there was presented an issue of fact for the jury which cannot now be disturbed.
Defendant further claims that in any event there was no proper basis, either by the pleadings or under the evidence, for any more than nominal damages.
Under plaintiff’s testimony as to the conversation preceding the sale in 1919 Froedtert said that he would rather see plaintiff “make the commission than an outside man, that is, a business broker or a real-estate man.” The only testimony upon which the jury’s assessment of damages at five per cent, of the sale price can be supported is that given by plaintiff’s witness, a real-estate and merchandise broker of eight years’ experience in Milwaukee. He testified that he was familiar with the usual and customary rates of compensation paid to brokers on a sale of a business, as apart from the sale of real estate, and that such rate was ten per cent, on sales of $5,000 or less, and in excess of that five per cent.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit