New Jersey Department of Labor Workmen's Compensation Bureau July 1, 1925 (Silverman v. Warman)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-07-1925

On determination and rule for .judgment.

This matter-coming on to be heard on petition, answer and proofs taken thereunder on June 23d, 1925, July 15th and August 4th, petitioner being represented by Samuel Green-*911stone, Esquire, and respondent by Charles W. Weeks, Esquire, and the court having heard the testimony and the argument of respective counsel finds and determines—

1. Petitioner alleges that while he was in the employ of the respondent the 1st day of November, 1923, he met with' an accident while driving a horse and wagon, as a result of which he was thrown from the wagon and his foot crushed. In support of this allegation he testifies that he worked at the request of the respondent for a period of three weeks before the happening of this accident, carting potatoes continuously during that time from one or two railroad yards to the place of business of the respondent. The testimony of the petitioner'is inconsistent with the other witnesses he produced to show the employment, in that they all testified they saw him load the wagon with produce at the place of business of the respondent and drive off from there with the loaded wagon. The demeanor of the petitioner and his other witnesses while on the stand, taken together with the several irreconcilable discrepancies in their stories, persuade me to believe that they were not telling the truth and that the petitioner was not employed by the respondent, as he said. In fact, T think that some of the testimony produced by the petitioner amounts to a deliberate misstatement of the facts., I am confirmed in the belief that petitioner and his witnesses are not telling the truth by the testimony of Mr, Todd, who was called on petitioner’s behalf, but do not feel that any useful purpose will be served by repeating the substance of Mr. Todd’s testimony in this determination.

2.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.