United States Court of Claims May 12, 1925, No. 34755 (Huron Navigation Corp. v. United States)
Also known as
United States · · · 12-05-1925
lead-opinion
*802MEMORANDUM BY THE COURT
Upon the findings as made and the separate opinion filed, four members of the court concur in the judgment rendered, but entertain the view that plaintiff’s vessel William O’Brien was taken by the Government under lawful authority and was not delivered to the Government under contract. See Gulf Refining Company case, 58 C. Cls. 559, 577, 578. The findings show, however, that after the vessel was requisitioned and had passed under Government control the plaintiff undertook to operate her on the time charter basis and rates stated by the Shipping Board. For her earnings during the voyage to France plaintiff should respond. Gulf Refining Gompamy eme, supra. The rate of compensation for this voyage was $6.25 per ton per month from October 19 to November 19, 1917. On the latter date the vessel was taken possession of by another agency of the Government, acting under lawful authority, and the vessel, with its crew, supplies, and stores, passed into a different service of the Government. The Government’s answer and counterclaim practically admit that from the date of this last-named taking over until her redelivery to plaintiff the vessel was under bareboat charter. Other items of recovery are mentioned in the court’s conclusion.
concurrence-opinion
Graham, Judge:
While concurring in the conclusion reached by the court, I wish to express my view of the case.
On October 15, 1917, and for some time prior thereto, the plaintiff owned the steamship Willicum O’Brien. On October 12 the United States Shipping Board sent a telegram to the Huron Navigation Co., in care of the Cosmopolitan Shipping Co.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit