Appellate Court of Illinois June 22, 1925, Gen. No. 29,839 (Citizens Trust & Savings Bank v. Dresher)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-06-1925

Mr. Justice Johnston

delivered the opinion of the court.

This is an appeal by the Citizens Trust & Savings Bank, the plaintiff, from a judgment overruling the demurrer of the plaintiff to the plea of the statute of limitations filed by Ernest I. Dresher, the defendant, to the amended declaration of the plaintiff.

The action was one of trover brought by the plaintiff to recover the value of certain stock certificates alleged to have been converted by the defendant to his own use. To the original declaration the defendant pleaded the general issue and discharge in bankruptcy. The plaintiff demurred to the plea of discharge in bankruptcy and the demurrer was overruled. The plaintiff then filed an amended declaration. The defendant filed three pleas to the amended declaration, ■ — the general issue, discharge in bankruptcy and the statute of limitations. The plaintiff demurred to the plea of discharge in bankruptcy and to the plea of the statute of limitations. The court sustained the plaintiff’s demurrer to the plea of discharge in bankruptcy and overruled the plaintiff’s demurrer to the plea of the statute of limitations. The plaintiff elected to abide by the amended declaration.

The theory on which the court overruled the plaintiff’s demurrer to the plea of the statute of limitations was that the plaintiff’s amended declaration stated a new cause of action, and that more than five years had intervened between the date of the alleged conversion by the defendant and the date of the filing of the amended declaration.

The question to be determined is whether the amended declaration stated a new cause of action.

The original declaration was substantially as follows :

“First Count: On May 27th plaintiff was possessed of securities (listing securities in question) of the value of $10,000. Plaintiff lost the securities and they came into possession of defendant by finding.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.