Appellate Court of Illinois March 31, 1925 (LaForest v. Chicago & Eastern Illinois Railway Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-03-1925

Mr. Justice Barry

delivered the opinion of the court.

Appellee’s intestate, who was five and one-half years of age, resided with her parents three-quarters of a mile north of Fayville and % about 200 feet from appellant’s track. On December 5, 1922, the child was struck and killed by one of appellant’s trains. Her mother ivas appointed administratrix and this suit, brought to recover for her death, resulted in a verdict and judgment for $1,800. The case went to the jury on the third and fourth counts of the declaration as amended. When those counts were amended appellant pleaded the statute of limitations thereto and a demurrer to the pleas was sustained. Appellant then extended the general issue to the amended counts.

Appellant insists that the original counts did not state a cause of action; that as amended they introduced a new cause of action to which the statute of limitations was a bar and that the court erred in sustaining the demurrer to its special pleas. It was held in Romani v. Shoal Creek Coal Co., 191 Ill. App. 521, that when a defendant pleads the general issue to amended counts after a demurrer to its plea of the statute of limitations had been sustained it was in no position to question the court’s ruling on the demurrer. The Supreme Court did not pass on that question but held that the amended counts did not state a new cause of action. Romani v. Shoal Creek Coal Co., 271 Ill. 360.

It is claimed that the original counts did not state a cause of action because there was no averment that the parents of the child were in the exercise of due care for her safety. Each count averred that the child was in the exercise of due care and caution and that was sufficient to negative contributory negligence on the part of her parents. Passwaters v. Lake Erie & W. R. Co., 188 Ill. App. 121; Elenz v. Conrad, 115 Iowa 183, 88 N. W. 337.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.