Supreme Court of the United States April 12, 1926, 14, Original (Massachusetts v. New York)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-04-1926

*80

Me. Justice Stone

delivered the opinion of the Court.

This is an original suit in equity brought by the Commonwealth of Massachusetts against the State of New York, the City of Rochester in New York, and certain corporations and individuals, to quiet title to land located

*81

in- the City of Rochester, and to enjoin the City from taking it by eminent domain, or in the alternative, to have the amount of compensation for the taking determined by this Court. The case was heard upon bill and answer and the report qf a Special Master appointed, to take proofs and to make an advisory report upon' the questions of fact raised by the pleadings, except as to the amount of damages to be paid for the property if taken by eminent domain.

The land in dispute is a narrow strip of about twenty-1 five acres fronting upon Lake Ontario within the city limits of Rochester. By the Treaty of Hartford, entered into between New York and Massachusetts, December 16, 1786, land within the territorial limits of New York was granted to Massachusetts in private ownership. The title to the land in controversy depends upon the meaning and effect of this treaty, and upon the construction of a subsequent conveyance by Massachusetts of a part of the land thus acquired, through which conveyance the several defendants other than the State of New York derive their title.

Before 1786, Massachusetts and .New York claimed, under Conflicting royal grants, both sovereignty arid title of a large area of what is now western New York. The controversy was settled by the Treaty of Hartford by which Massachusetts gave up all its claim to sovereignty over the territory, and its claim to private.ownership '.in part of it, and. New York ceded.to Massachusetts,- “ thp Right of pre-emption of the . Soil from the native Indians and all other the Estate, Right, Title and Property (the Right~and Title' of- Government Sovereignty and Jurisdiction excepted) ’winch the State of New York hath . . .

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.