District Court, D. Delaware April 30, 1926, 582 (Universal Oil Products Co. v. Skelly Oil Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-04-1926

MORRIS, District Judge.

Universal Oil Products Company filed its bill of complaint against Skelly Oil Company for infringe-ment of specified claims of United States letters patent Nos. 1,281,884, 1,484,445, 1,517,-830,1,525,281, and 1,534,927. The allegation of infringement is the general one — “that * * * the * * * defendant * * * did unlawfully and wrongfully practice the inventions of said letters patent and each of them described and claimed in the claims thereof. * * * ” The defendant, relying upon equity rule 20, the asserted complexity of its processes and apparatus, and an offer made by it to permit the plaintiff, before complying with the order sought, to make a full and complete examination of defendant’s plant, processes, and apparatus, now moves for an order requiring the plaintiff to set out in a bill of particulars “(a) the particular step or steps charged to embody each of the steps of each of the process claims relied upon; and (b) the particular element or elements of apparatus which are charged to embody each of the elements of claim 4 of patent No. 1,281,884.” The plaintiff opposes the motion upon the ground that an order granting the motion would run counter to the great weight of authority and would be in direct conflict with the decision of the Court of Appeals for this Circuit in Morton Trust Co. v. American Car

&

Foundry Co., 129 F. 916, 64 C. C. A. 367.

As I understand the motion, it is in effect that the plaintiff be required (l) to set out the specific steps in defendant’s processes and the specific parts or elements of defendant’s apparatus which constitute the alleged infringement of the process and apparatus claims, respectively, in suit, and (2) to parallel and compare each step of each process claim and each element of the apparatus claim in suit, respectively, with the alleged infringing steps of defendant’s processes and with the like parts of its apparatus.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.