Court of Appeals of Kentucky (pre-1976) October 15, 1926 (Briggs v. Davis, Director General)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-10-1926

Opinion oe the Court by

Judge Dietzman

Affirming.

This is the second appeal of this case. The opinion on the former appeal, where may he found a statement of the facts and applicable law, is reported in 201 Ky. 784, 258 S. W. 663.

On the first trial, the present appellant recovered a verdict against the present appellee in the sum of $15,-000.00. The judgment on that verdict was reversed in the opinion above referred to on the ground that the present appellant had' assumed the risk of the injury he had sustained. On that appeal the present appellant had insisted that the evidence in his case brought it within that exception to the general rule of assumption of risk which provides that where the servant acts in obedience to the direct order of his superior, and the risk in doing the work is not so imminent that a person of ordinary prudence would refuse to take it, the risk involved is then

*94

shifted'to-ánd.-rests upon the employer. -Answering thát contention, we said: ‘

‘‘But we cannot assent to this; the evidence shows without -contradiction that it was the regular duty of the fireman to take water into the tank, and the fact that on the occasion of his injury it so happened that he was given a specific direction by the engineer to take water could not have the effect to release appellee of the assumption of risk. The direction of the engineer was equivalent only to a suggestion to the fireman that the engine 'needed water, and that he in the exercise of ‘his ordinary and customary duties should see that it was filled. There was neither direct nor inferred assurance of safety; it amounted only to a suggestion to appellee he should perform his-customary duties, in-taking water.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.